Time-course analysis of the neuroanatomical correlates of sexual arousal evoked by erotic video stimuli in healthy males (2010)

OBJECTIVE:

To assess the dynamic activations of the key brain areas associated with the time-course of the sexual arousal evoked by visual sexual stimuli in healthy male subjects.

MATERIALS AND METHODS:

Fourteen right-handed heterosexual male volunteers participated in this study. Alternatively combined rest period and erotic video visual stimulation were used according to the standard block design. In order to illustrate and quantify the spatiotemporal activation patterns of the key brain regions, the activation period was divided into three different stages as the EARLY, MID and LATE stages.

RESULTS:

For the group result (p < 0.05), when comparing the MID stage with the EARLY stage, a significant increase of the brain activation was observed in the areas that included the inferior frontal gyrus, the supplementary motor area, the hippocampus, the head of the caudate nucleus, the midbrain, the superior occipital gyrus and the fusiform gyrus. At the same time, when comparing the EARLY stage with the MID stage, the putamen, the globus pallidus, the pons, the thalamus, the hypothalamus, the lingual gyrus and the cuneus yielded significantly increased activations. When comparing the LATE stage with the MID stage, all the above mentioned brain regions showed elevated activations except the hippocampus.

CONCLUSION:

Our results illustrate the spatiotemporal activation patterns of the key brain regions across the three stages of visual sexual arousal.

A part from the very limited information available from human subjects with brain lesions, the studies that have been conducted on subjects with epilepsy, the rare studies of electrical stimulation of the brain and animal studies, and especially those using rodents, have been the major source of information about the neural mechanisms that control sexual arousal/behavior (1). Yet the inferences and information from the animal research are not sufficient since human sexual behavior has species-specific characteristics and human sexual arousal is dependent on the complex influences of culture and context (2). It has recently been proposed that human sexual arousal, which is usually triggered by external stimuli or endogenous factors, is a multidimensional experience that’s comprised of four closely interrelated and coordinated components: a cognitive component, an emotional component, a motivational component and a physiological component (3). The cognitive component’s contributions to sexual arousal are not completely known, but they involve the appraisal and evaluation of the stimulus, categorization of the stimulus as sexual and an affective response (3, 4). The activation of the physiological system that coordinates sexual function in both sexes can be divided into central arousal, peripheral non-genital arousal and genital arousal (5).

Modern neuroimaging techniques allow the in vivo observation of brain activation that is correlated with sensory or cognitive processing and emotional states. The previous studies using positron emission tomography (PET) (3, 4, 6–8) or functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) (9–15) have mostly been focused on visual sexual stimuli such as visual erotica, and these studies have shown increased neural activities in several cerebral regions, including the inferior frontal gyrus, the inferior temporal gyrus, the cingulate gyrus, the insula gyrus, the corpus callosum, the thalamus, the hypothalamus, the amygdala, the caudate nucleus and the globus pallidus. The fMRI measures the changes of the regional cerebral activity through blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD) signal detection, and this modality has methodological advantages over PET: fMRI is noninvasive and it requires no radiotracer injection as in PET, the fMRI temporal resolution is greater than that of PET, which allows detecting the early response to stimuli, and fMRI can be used not only to study the cerebral responses of a group of subjects, but also to study the responses of individual subjects, which is more difficult to do with PET (14, 16, 17).

Moreover, studies are needed to assess and separate the temporal associations of the central nervous system activity and the peripheral/end organ responses to visual sexual stimulation (10, 18). Therefore, the present study used a 3T fMRI scanner to analyze the dynamic activations of the key brain regions associated with the time-course of the sexual arousal evoked by visual sexual stimulation without any invasive objective and subjective measurements via penile plethysmography. In order to identify and quantify the spatiotemporal activation patterns of the key brain regions, each activation period of our fMRI paradigm was divided into three different stages, that is, the EARLY, MID and LATE stages, and this provided information on the time-course neural activation.

This study was designed to evaluate the time-course information on the brain activation associated with the sexual arousal evoked by visual stimuli in healthy males.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

RESULTS

Subjective Ratings of the Visual Sexual Stimuli

The participating subjects rated the visual sexual stimuli in terms of attractiveness and physical arousal based on a scale ranging from 1 (nil) to 5 (maximal increase). The reported scores (mean ± standard deviation [SD]) were 2.9 ± 0.62 for attractiveness and 3.0 ± 0.88 for sexual arousal (Table 1).

 

Table 1

Male Subjects’ Rating of Erotic Content According o Attractiveness and Physical Arousal

fMRI Data

Figure 1 illustrates the group result with the fixed-effect activation patterns (p < 0.05), during the EARLY (Fig. 1A), MID (Fig. 1B) and LATE (Fig. 1C) stages with respect to the rest period, respectively, overlaid on the Colin Holmes 27 (ch2) template of the international consortium for brain mapping (ICBM). Tables 2, ​,33 and ​and44 show the summary of the time-course brain activations with significance (p < 0.05), which were extracted from Figure 1: the EARLY (Table 2), MID (Table 3) and LATE stages (Table 4).

 

Fig. 1

Regional activation maps (p < 0.05) obtained from group results. Activation contrasts are overlaid over ch2 template: EARLY stage versus REST period (A), MID stage versus REST period (B) and LATE stage versus REST period (C).

 

Table 2

Male Group Results from Fixed-Effect Analysis and Using One-Sample t Tests (threshold significance was set at p < 0.05)

 

Table 3

Male Group Results from Fixed-Effect Analysis Using One-Sample t Tests (threshold significance was set at p < 0.05)

 

Table 4

Male Group Results with Fixed-Effects Analysis Using One-Sample t Tests (threshold significance was set at p < 0.05)

Figure 2 compares the brain activations (p < 0.05) during the EARLY, MID and LATE stages with respect to the REST period, respectively. When comparing the MID stage with the EARLY stage, a significant increase of the brain activation was observed in the areas of the inferior frontal gyrus, the supplementary motor area, the hippocampus, the head of the caudate nucleus, the midbrain, the superior occipital gyrus and the fusiform gyrus. At the same time, when comparing the EARLY stage with the MID stage, the putamen, the globus pallidus, the pons, the thalamus, the hypothalamus, the lingual gyrus and the cuneus yielded significantly increased activations. Particularly, the globus pallidus and pons yielded no activity during the MID stage.

 

Fig. 2

Comparison of activations of different key regions of sexual arousal during each stage with respect to rest condition (p < 0.05).

When comparing the LATE stage with the MID stage, all the above mentioned ROIs yielded significantly increased activations, except for the hippocampus.

DISCUSSION

The participating subjects rated the visual sexual stimuli as moderately sexually attractive and physically arousing. When contrasting each stage versus the rest period (Fig. 2), we were able to see the spatiotemporal activation patterns in the key ROIs across the three one-minute durations during the sexual arousal.

Various medical imaging studies on visual sexual arousal have recently been performed to evaluate the brain centers associated with the sexual mechanism and function. However, most of these studies have produced different results and conclusions, and this has created uncertainty in the field (6–15). The main reasons for the differing findings are presumably due to a lack of standardized criteria for what constitutes significant activation over the basal levels and the different methodologies that have been used for inducing arousal and recording it. Hence, it is obvious that it is very difficult at present to give a consensus account of the human brain activation to sexual arousal. Since this study has approached the issue with a different view, we hope our findings have resolved some of the contradictory results.

In this study, visual sexual stimulus of a 3-minute long duration was used in order to activate the complex cerebral mechanism involved in central arousal, peripheral non-genital arousal and genital arousal. An increase in activation was observed from the EARLY stage to the LATE stage in the amygdala, the inferior frontal gyrus, the superior occipital gyrus, the fusiform gyrus, the supplementary motor area, the head of the caudate nucleus and the midbrain regions. The EARLY stage was intended to determine the neural correlates of the early sexual arousal responses (i.e., the neural correlates of the cognitive, emotional and motivational components), the MID stage was intended to identify the brain centers that have an influence on the aspects of the onset of a genital response, e.g., the neural correlates of the perception of penile tumescence, which is a process that occurs with a longer latency, and the LATE stage was intended to illustrate the neural responses that pertain to the state of fully developed sexual arousal, which is associated with a higher level of genital responses (14). Therefore, the increase in activation in the above mentioned regions across the three stages confirms that cognitive and physiological components operate through distinct mechanisms and circuitry, although they are likely to affect each other (25).

Moreover, we were able to find variable activations at the midbrain regions during the period of erotic visual stimulation. The substantia nigra and the surrounding areas are responsible for the production of dopamine, which seems to play a major role in penile erection and sexual arousal (26, 27) and there is substantial evidence that dopamine facilitates male sexual behavior (9, 27). Experiments with animals have also shown that the midbrain structures are involved in erection (28, 29). Therefore, we hope that this result is good evidence for the concordance between men’s genital responses and the subjective assessments of arousal.

During the EARLY stage as compared to the other stages, both the thalamus and hypothalamus displayed elevated activation. Yet the activation of the hypothalamus in response to visual sexual stimuli has been an inconsistent finding in human (11). This conflicting result is in fact consistent with the contradictory findings in the animal literature on the relation between sexual cues and the activation of brain regions that have been implicated in sexual behavior (30–32).

The next very interesting structure is the amygdala. The amygdala seems to have a key role in processing the meaning of the ongoing sexual stimulus. If the stimulus is processed as positive, then the amygdala will turn on the cascade of neurobiological events leading to full physical sexual arousal, and if the stimulus is processed as negative, then the amygdala will inhibit or totally block any further physical or emotional arousal (5). In the fMRI studies, there is the possibility that the lack of an amygdalar response is related to susceptibility artifact. Therefore, there is conflict concerning the response of the human amygdala to sexual stimuli, with some studies (6, 10, 13, 15) reporting an activation, while others (3, 8, 12, 14) did not show any amygdalar response. As far as the previous animal studies are concerned, they suggest that different parts of the amygdala are involved in the facilitation of erectile functions (33, 34).

In our study, the activation pattern of the amygdala showed elevated activation during the LATE stage with respect to the other stages. Particularly, no activation was found during the first one-minute period. At this same time period, other studies (9, 11) were unable to confirm amygdala activation during penile erection. Interestingly, amygdala deactivation is related to orgasm (35). Therefore, we have come to the conclusion that the activation of the hypothalamus and amydala reflect not only the physiological arousal, but also cognitive processing of sexual stimuli, such as motivation and desire.

The supplementary motor area is involved in the activation patterns of the insula, and these results are consistent with the findings of other studies (9, 11). Particularly, the insular region lies in the proximity of the secondary somatosensory cortex and the insular region is bidirectionally connected to it; both areas relay visceral and somatosensory perceptions related to the processing of the cognitive content of the incoming sensory stimuli (9, 10). A previous study that used relatively short sexual stimulation periods (21 s long) and still erotic pictures to determine the neural correlates of early sexual arousal responses (the neural correlates of cognitive, emotional and motivational components) has shown that visual sexual stimulation caused activities in the right secondary somatosensory cortex, which is a region that’s been implicated in the perception of emotions, and in frontal premotor areas, which have been implicated in motor imagery (14).

Moreover, in a comparative study that used video and still pictures, the hypothalamus, the anterior cingulate gyrus and the insular and secondary somatosensory cortices were found to be activated only by viewing video clips and therefore, the researchers came to the conclusion that the activation of these structures should be related to a more complex and articulated level of sexual response (10).

In conclusion, this study provides valuable information on the spatiotemporal dynamics associated with sexual arousal across the three different stages of the activation of the relevant brain areas by using BOLD-based fMRI. This study may have an important practical impact from the view of its potential clinical application for evaluating the process of sexual arousal as well as sexual dysfunction in men.

Footnotes

References